Skip to product information
1 of 28

The Mystery Date Quarterly Subscription

The Mystery Date Quarterly Subscription

Regular price $55.00 USD
Regular price Sale price $55.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Tax included.

Mystery Blind Date Book Quarterly Subscription—

The Whole Package

Love a good surprise but still want a little say in what you're reading? Meet The Mystery Date!

Every three months, you'll receive a new blind date with a book, complete with all the little extras that make opening your package feel like a treat. But unlike our Horror and Seasonal subscriptions, you get to choose your genre every single quarter!

Maybe you're in the mood for a thriller this time, a little romance next time, or you're feeling adventurous and want us to surprise you completely. It's totally up to you!

Same blind date. Different type every time.

How Does The Mystery Date Work?

Before each quarterly box, we'll send you an email asking you to pick your next genre.

Stick with something you already love, try something new, or select "Surprise Me!" and leave the decision entirely up to us!

Your book will still be a mystery. You just get to decide what kind of story you're in the mood for.

If you don't submit your genre selection by the deadline provided in your email, we'll choose a genre for you.

This is a quarterly subscription! You'll receive four boxes per year and be charged once every three months.

What's Inside Your Blind Date?

Each quarterly box includes:

  • One surprise book in like-new condition, in your chosen genre

  • One laminated bookmark

  • Four large, high-quality specialty stickers

  • One specialty sticker sheet

  • A high-quality tea bag (or another bagged drink depending on the season!)

  • Specialty wrapping paper, twine, and a handmade wax seal

  • One collectible keepsake charm for your Annual Subscriber Reading Card

  • A book review sheet

With your first box, and again at the beginning of each new yearly subscription cycle, you'll also receive:

  • Your Annual Subscriber Reading Card

  • A sheet of star rating stickers to rate your books throughout the year

Our like-new books may have been previously owned, but they'll have little to no visible wear and look and feel almost brand new.

A Few Extra Perks Just for Subscribers

Because being part of the Coven should come with a few perks!

  • Annual Subscriber Reading Card: You'll receive your very own subscriber reading card with your first box, then a brand-new one at the start of each yearly subscription cycle! Keep track of your four quarterly reads, rate each book with your star stickers, collect your keepsake charms along the way, and earn subscriber-only rewards for completing your card.

  • Keepsake Charms: Collect a new charm with every quarterly box to mark your reading progress.

  • Subscriber-Only Rewards: Complete your reading card to unlock a special little something just for members of the Coven!

Subscription Details & Cancellations

Your subscription renews quarterly, with four boxes shipped throughout the year in February, May, August, and November.

Shipping windows:

  • February 1–10

  • May 1–10

  • August 1–10

  • November 1–10

Need to cancel? Just email Belladonnabookcoven@gmail.com before the cancellation deadline for your upcoming box.

Cancellation deadlines:

  • February box — December 31

  • May box — March 31

  • August box — June 30

  • November box — September 30

Cancellation requests received after these dates will apply to the following shipment.

What If I Already Own the Book?

Already met your blind date? No worries! We know there's always a chance you might unwrap a book you've already read or own.

Subscribers are allowed one book exchange per subscription year. Just reach out within 5 days of delivery, and return the book in undamaged condition. Once we receive it, we'll send you a replacement!

Only the book needs to be returned, so all those extra goodies are yours to keep!

To help avoid another repeat, we may ask for your Goodreads, StoryGraph, or a photo of your bookshelf.

$55 every three months, plus shipping.

View full details

Join Subscription Waitlist